CR 2014-052 Approve Final Design Plans and Authorize Bidding: Cottageville Park, Phase I ImprovementsGcvy OF
C.511110.
N 0 P K I N S
May 29, 2014
Council Report 2014-052
APPROVE FINAL DESIGN PLANS AND AUTHORIZE BIDDING:
COTTAGEVILLE PARK, PHASE I IMPROVEMENTS
Proposed Action.
Staff recommends the following motion: Move that Council approve the final
design plans and authorize bidding of the Cottageville Park, Phase
Improvement project.
This action precedes the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District Board
consideration of final plan approval and bidding the project.
Overview.
Staff presented a 60% design review with City Council at its May 13 work
session. The project team presented the project design at a public open house
event on May 20 and received numerous comments and general affirmation of
the overall project intent and design elements. The project design is now
essentially completed and City Council approval is needed prior to the June 12
Minnehaha Creek Watershed District Board meeting where they will consider
design approval and whether or not to advance the project to public bidding.
Primary Issues to Consider.
• 90% construction cost and total project cost estimates, project funding
• Design elements
• City Council and Public Open House project feedback
• Project Schedule
Supporting Documents.
• Project area sketches, construction plan excerpts, sheets
Steven J. Stadler, Public Works Director
Council Report 2014-052
Page 2
Analvsis of Issues
• 90% construction cost estimate, total project cost estimate, project
funding
Current project cost estimates are as follows:
90% design construction cost estimate = $1,654,198
This is a reduction from the 60% construction cost estimate of $1,836,896. Plus,
the construction contingency has been increased from 5% to 10% (a $36,500
increase) and $40,000 is now included in the construction cost as a possible
alternate bid for demolition of the duplex at 431/433 Blake Road.
The total project cost estimate is now: $1,885,758
The project funding is as follows:
State BWSR Grant: $410,250
Henn Cty Grant: $15,000
Shepard of the Hills project donation: $12,050
Hopkins Storm Sewer Fund: $1,000,000
Hopkins Park Capital Improvement Fund: $408,000
Water and Sanitary Sewer Funds: $45,000
TOTAL PROJECT BUDGET: $1,890,300
The project funding through the storm sewer utility fund has been increased from
$750,000 to $1,000,000. This will be done by slightly increasing the storm sewer
bonding amount for 2015.
• Design Elements
The design elements include:
- underground storm water storage/treatment/infiltration to prevent 25+ lbs/yr total
phosphorus and 10 tons/year of sediment from entering the creek
- Two park entrances and concrete paths through park, creek access
Council Report 2014-052
Page 3
- Extensive landscaping features, including: ornamental trees, multi -trunk trees,
canopy trees, evergreen trees, shrub beds, groundcover beds, perennial flower
beds, drip and lawn irrigation
- flexible electrical service into site
- pathway lighting with photocell and timer control
- community garden area
- play area with raised mound adventure trail, adventure trail sliding and climbing
play features, central play structure, lookout point structure, shade trees, seating
• City Council and Public Open House Feedback
Community garden: confirmed planting soil depths & connection between play
area and garden, have added a raised bed garden area - will coordinate 90%
design with community garden reps that attended the open house.
Park play amenities: no clear winner on the main play structure, strong support
for the adventure trail & associated play elements, swing area added to design,
proposed Evos play structure will interest older kids, teens will have lawn areas
for soccer, Frisbee, etc. + basketball play court.
Lighting: Extensive pathway lighting will have photocell and timer controls similar
to other parks lighting.
Parking: This was a concern expressed by at least one nearby resident.
Besides the limited number of parallel parking stalls along the access road/alley,
it was mentioned that the City hopes to partner with the future developer at the
cold storage site to have co -use parking available along the Lake Street side of
that redevelopment area.
Plantings: The final design will include some additional tree planting along the
south side of the alley to the east of the project area.
Miscellaneous: Staff will include a notice in the July Hopkins Highlights regarding
the opportunity to purchase a memorial bench as part of the Cottageville Park
improvements. An upcoming project announcement sign will be placed at the
park.
• Project Schedule
June 3: Hopkins City Council design approval, authorize bidding
June 12: MCWD final plan approval, authorize bidding
June 10 — July 1: Advertise for bids
Council Report 2014-052
Page 4
June 24: Pre -Bid Meeting
July 1: Inform Hopkins City Council on bids received/recommendation
July 10: Bid award: MCWD Board
August — October 2014: Construction
,
�r t Envy Mora-ri�entadon
Alley
"'� j t " • — �..... Parallel Parking
.�..._.., �� 1 '�• G"'�.' _.. �"r .�
1 •� '_rCummuai Existing Ball
Court
i..� • . If
Out Parcel Y, 5 e
1 " ? Srvings ]unioo
rSccer
&Play Areas
/-1Terrace� real Lawn with Storm ! }�`-'f,---}„L ✓ `"�'t }
v 4 ZZv • 1I.� ' Water Management ,
't System Below
4 J,Z.,,,,� Educational ,� _
�, -Summer Soccer & ' !
Exhibits Informal Play
1 _Srage Viewing Area
Sle p ling Sioncc
t I I -1 � i'�• s--�.�
,j` v Lawn
v
+l J Creek Overlooky ( ✓ Lx6il ir, ✓ �r ;
f� and Riv
erfron[
1 --, Planting ” • �r
d /
rte.
Creek Overlook Park
with MCW D
Education I Exhibits t
s y Canoe Pull
ffp
wo tormwa[er
ry�o-r.
, X Canoe Launch and
R "� O u t ca I l I +r' '
CreeksideViewing
• � �i _ _., e5c �,, , `.,�E�� ` ` `.tea
Guelyir Mini Park 41 �' 1 �- •r
k
poreiwal for Kiosk^ /
Connection to
6u�� rn Entire Cree= < _.•
�, Regional Trail
01 hSpaccSystem) System
• J P 'x
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 240'
I"= 30' ar fidl rru (3r,
HART HOW k RTON MINNEHAHA CREEK CORRIDOR COMMUNITY TRAILS INITIATIVE Cottageville Park Conceptual Master Plan
May 22, 2014
e ,• a
f+ 4 # Creek ASi
,��,.•�'S � � � `�. f~ � ,• ccessteppng • • .. Educational
r ( + Stones & Seating Exhibits
Stormwater
o �+•.'_ .'`'`',�.''' �`..1; >. .yG Outfall
r
b` ry F c
L wn
r ` \
r
d
v
� l
' y
. �• Creek Overlook{
and Riverfront
: + y, ✓ .: `Planting %� �� � �'".�.-�` ?` . , r^"`•t1 n.,.
71
..�� fir* ?`
tt Wt .`,'� � £ ` � � Al �� -•.. .
HART HOwE RTON MINNEHAHA CREEK CORRIDOR COMMUNITY TRAILS INITIATIVE Creek Buffer Concept
k R �,�.-...,.,.,,. pM«> x.,,H..n,a,..,. � ,a4..a T ., „ ...�,.�..�,,,.,..,x,�,•,..,. May 22. 2014
b
cd
cd
CQ
r �
vo
PLANTING ZONES
OUTFALL CHANNEL AND DRAINAGE SWALE
CREEK BANK PLANTING WITH STEPPING
STONES
SODDED LAWN
PATH EDGE PLANTING
WEST PARK ENTRY
ZONE G BRIDGE ABUTMENT PLANTINGS
ZONE 7 EAST PARK ENTRY
CREEK EDGE
HART I HOW E RTON MINNEHAHA CREEK CORRIDOR COMMUNITY TRAILS INITIATIVE Creek Buffer Planting Zones
May 22, 2014
Low Fence & Rabbit
Protection All Around Garden
Entrance Gate
Small Flowering Trees
Flower Bed at Entry—
Park Sidewalk &
Maintenance Access
8'-10' wide Garden Beds -
4' wide Crushed Gravel Paths
Flowering Shrubs outside of
Fence
Garden Water Faucet —
Garden Seating
O I ....... ....I...... ..... I.r......... I ........... I...........I ........... I.......................I
0 to 20 30 40 50 60 80'
i.. to' erf*#dzrt6:z47
va— t4—.—
Lookout Point &
Treehouse
(See image board)
Adventure Trail on
Adventure Trail Sliding &
Climbing Play
(See image board)
Play Area Seating
Low Fence
Sloping Play Surface
Accessible Wood
Fiber Surface
CENTRAL PLAY
STRUCTURE OPTIONS
`(See image board)
Cottageville Park
HART H O W E RTO N MINNEHAHA CREEK CORRIDOR COMMUNITY TRAILS INITIATIVE Community Garden and Play Area
4 HIIr4!'t WisEtitw ST M'i}M NN"fx1sTlS.r. Yn.tY%Ip}}vp
n..w�.w.......r.....«..�.r.».�iwt+...»,. �r+..,,..,..a.w..,...�lr.}-..a..»......,.vit.,�a....,..
May 20, 2014
f-
i
Garden Vine house / connectionito garden
+ 2'
Overlook/play equipment —
MONO"
Wall with fence above/ approx. T height
Adventure Path /Poured in place
+ q,
Custom play equipment
+3'
Land form /Artificial turf
r
N_ a
Evos Playstructure /
Engineered Wood Fiber (EWF) surface
Shade / Seating / Sand?
HART HOweRTON MINNEHAHA CREEK CORRIDOR COMMUNITY TRAILS INITIATIVE
w Swings/EWF
flagshi)k
p
recreation
Cottageville Park
Preliminary Equipment and Landform
May 28, 2014
/001�-,-
Evos Play Structure Option
HART HOWERTONflagship
` MINNEHAHA CREEK CORRIDOR COMMUNITY TRAILS INITIATIVE
Cottageville Park
Play Area
May 28, 2014
1
.,� nv-__
'x
Potential Swing Option
HART HOWERTONflagship
` MINNEHAHA CREEK CORRIDOR COMMUNITY TRAILS INITIATIVE
Cottageville Park
Play Area
May 28, 2014
Embankment Play Equipment Examples
HART H O W E R T O Nhlk Cottageville Park
�W MINNEHAHA CREEK CORRIDOR COMMUNITY TRAILS INITIATIVE Adventure Trail Sliding and Climbing Play
May 28, 2014
• r ,
r CO MAITY GARDEN PLAY AREA
r
HART HOWE RTON MINNEHAHA CREEK CORRIDOR COMMUNITY TRAILS INITIATIVE
Cottageville Park Lighting Concept
May 28, 2014
Ili
SII
rl
40
0
ANTICIPATED BRUSH
REMOVAL AREA (TYP)
f
9
17
..........
9Q4_
X�ox—oq
y-90
...........
X—
SBRG
REMOVE TREE (TYP)3 ,
3!
... 43&
W3, 1
51 0
I 4
I
122
r 50
6 SBRG 1
IP 9041
CO2
y
i 99
100
Ol
me
90 t3
;
7- 61, 69
..
0
YO
01 0
12 1 TRANSPLANT K
3 RG
4
5
0
b 124
ol09C,
9 903
J7
TI
N
12
0M
C,
om
20
o
--907--� - 9LN Q ==�-f
- - - - - - -
968.
•01
P
900-908
13
om
.909
118 _-\l 17
0M03-
9�02114
i(D
om
01'
om
TREE ID
TYPE
DBH (IN.)
STATUS
1
ASH
20
REMOVE
2
ASH
20
REMOVE
3
ASH
22
REMOVE
4
ELM
30
PRESERVE
5
ELM
8
PRESERVE
6
ELM
5
PRESERVE
7
HACKBERRY
7
PRESERVE
8
ELM
23
PRESERVE
9
ELM
9
PRESERVE
10
BOX ELDER
15
PRESERVE
11
ASH
12
PRESERVE
12
BASSWOOD
8
PRESERVE
13
ASH
10
PRESERVE
14
BASSWOOD
8
PRESERVE
15
BASSWOOD
6
PRESERVE
16
SILVER MAPLE
36
PRESERVE
17
CRABAPPLE
5
PRESERVE
18
UNKNOWN
8
PRESERVE
19
BASSWOOD
6
PRESERVE
20
UNKNOWN
4
PRESERVE
21
UNKNOWN
6
PRESERVE
22
DEAD
5
REMOVE
23
UNKNOWN
4
REMOVE
24
UNKNOWN
4
REMOVE
25
ASH
4
REMOVE
26
ELM
5
REMOVE
27
WALNUT
21
PRESERVE
28
WALNUT
22
PRESERVE
29
UNKNOWN
4
REMOVE
30
UNKNOWN
5
REMOVE
31
CRABAPPLE
5
REMOVE
32
HACKBERRY
4
REMOVE
33
ELM
11
REMOVE
34
ASH
4
REMOVE
35
WALNUT
18
REMOVE
36
WALNUT
14
REMOVE
37
ELM
4
REMOVE
38
ELM
21
REMOVE
39
WALNUT
4
PRESERVE
40
WALNUT
10
PRESERVE
41
WALNUT
16
PRESERVE
42
ELM
12
REMOVE
26
9e
43
WALNUT
9
PRESERVE
44
SPRUCE
6
PRESERVE
TREE
ALNUT
SH
15
5
---
REMOVE
16
NKNOWN
5
REMOVE
7
SH
11
REMOVE
34
LM
8
REMOVE
9
NKNOWN
17
PRESERVE
13
NKNOWN
14
PRESERVE
10
NKNOWN
6
PRESERVE
4
ALNUT
tj—
7
REMOVE
6
SH
4
REMOVE
8
SH
4
REMOVE
13
SH
5
REMOVE
12
ACKBERRY
5
PRESERVESH
22
REMOVE
7
REMOVELM
9
REMOVE
5
REMOVEALNUT
10
REMOVE
8
PRESERVE
TREE ID TYPE DBH (IN.)
STATUS
61
UNKNOWN
16
PRESERVE
62
ELM
7
REMOVE
63
BASSWOOD
34
REMOVE
64
ELM
9
REMOVE
65
ELM
13
REMOVE
66
ELM
10
REMOVE
67
BOX ELDER
4
PRESERVE
68
UNKNOWN
6
REMOVE
69
ELM
8
REMOVE
70
ELM
13
REMOVE
71
ELM
12
REMOVE
72
ELM
22
REMOVE
73
WALNUT
9
REMOVE
74
ELM
10
REMOVE
75
UNKNOWN
15
REMOVE
76
RED PINE
6
REMOVE
77
SCOTCH PINE
6
REMOVE
78
SPRUCE
2
TRANSPLANT
79
SPRUCE
3
TRANSPLANT
80
WALNUT
7
REMOVE
81
BASSWOOD
7
REMOVE
82
ELM
8
REMOVE
83
APPLE
16
REMOVE
84
APPLE
15
REMOVE
85
SPRUCE
16
REMOVE
86
SPRUCE
16
REMOVE
87
OAK
40
PRESERVE
88
ELM
7
REMOVE
89
ELM
16
REMOVE
90
ELM
17
REMOVE
91
ASH
8
REMOVE
92
BUROAK
24
PRESERVE
93
WILLOW
19
PRESERVE
94
APPLE
12
PRESERVE
95
ASH
1
REMOVE
96
WILLOW
16
PRESERVE
97
ASH
10
REMOVE
98
ELM
14
REMOVE
99
UNKNOW FRUIT
22
PRESERVE
100
SPRUCE
8
PRESERVE
101
SPRUCE
9
PRESERVE
102
SPRUCE
11
PRESERVE
103
1 COTTONWOOD
26
9e
PRESERVE
PRESERVE
105
BOX ELDER
18
PRESERVE
106
ELM
13
PRESERVE
107
COTTONWOOD
24
PRESERVE
108
ELM
10
PRESERVE
109
ASH
13
REMOVE
110
SILVER MAPLE
32
PRESERVE
111
ASH
20
PRESERVE
112
BIRCH
11
PRESERVE
113
BUR OAK
26
PRESERVE
114
ELM
8
PRESERVE
115
ELM
12
PRESERVE
116
ASH
8
PRESERVE
117
BUR OAK
30
PRESERVE
118
BUR OAK
46
PRESERVE
119
BUR OAK
32
PRESERVE
120
UNKNOWN
20
PRESERVE
TREED TYPE DBH (IN.) STATUS
121
UNKNOWN
4
REMOVE
122
UNKNOWN
3
REMOVE
123
UNKNOWN
3
REMOVE
124
UNKNOWN
7
PRESERVE