IV.3. Special Assessment Deferral Request – 11 Interlachen Road; BishopNovember 4, 2020 Council Report 2020-082
Special Assessment Deferral Request
11 Interlache� Rd, PID 20-117-21-32-0055
2019-10 Street Improvement Project
Pro�osed Action.
Staff recommends that the Council approve the following motion: Approve the ap�lication for
Deferral of S ecial Assessment for Vir inia A. Kirscht of 11 Interlachen Rd. for as lon = as she
meets the eli i�y requirements.
Overview:
The assessment roll for City Project 2019-10, 2020 Interlachen Park Street & Utility
Improvements was adopted by the City Council on March 16, 2020. City Code Section 2-120
allows for deferment of special assessments upon request for any homestead property owned by
a person who has attained the age of 65, or has not attained the age of 65, but is retired as a result
of a permanent and total disability, and it is determined to be a hardship for said owners to make
the payrnents. The hearing notices mailed to all affected property owners stated the procedures
to apply for such deferment are available from the Assessment Clerk. It was not necessary to file
an appeal at the assessment hearing. Ms. Kirscht has now applied for the deferment.
Ms. Kirscht has attained the age of 65 and indicates it is a hardship to pay the special assessment.
Ms. Kirscht's 2020 income falls below the income limit set in Section 2-120.
Primar�- Issues to Consider:
• Should the City grant the deferment?
Su ortin Information:
• Application for Deferral of Special Assessment
• Hopkins City Code Section 2-120 — Deferment of Special Assessment
• MN Statutes 435.193 Hardship Assessment Deferral for Seniors, Disabled, or Military
Persons
• MN Statues 435.195 Termination of Right to Deferred Payrnent
Analysis of the Issues:
Should the City grant the deferment?
Ms. Kirscht has demonstrated meeting the financial hardship requirements by providing
documentation from the Social Security �dministration stating her income as of O1/15/2020.
Staff recommends granting the deferment. The special assessment of $9,967.40 will be secure
by virtue of a lien filed against the property. This deferral terminates upon Ms. Kirscht's death,
sale of the property, loss of homestead status, or her annual income exceeds the annual income
limit. This deferral must be renewed annually during the term of the deferment not later than
September 30 of each year.
Alternatives •
1. Approve the special assessment deferment of $9,967.40 for Ms. Virginia A. Kirscht
of ll Interlachen Rd., Hopkins MN, PID #20-117-21-32-0055.
2. Do not approve the deferment.
Staff recommends alternative #1.
Melanie Ortiz
Accounting Technician, Special Assessments
�� �'}� �[3�K3N�
I-���F�%€ ��}i��, ��iI�E�4T'�
App�ic�i�n f�r �f�nral Qf S�ci�l Assessm�nt
I�t�r�hy m�lce applicat��an f�r defemai vf special assessment tl�ti� ''� +��day of 4 tT4�,� �L.. �
2(� .Z.�C3 fc�r the follnwi��; ��e�sm+ent: ,
L.�'�.�.�•�#ta� ���`��.`�" t�{{--lt� �`�.+�� ��t��.�tl�M��..rT
��°�.��- � �-�-,�.{-�a.- �ass � r ��-��c�t�� ;�-r� �� qr��. ��
I t��ders�d th�t this cfefenai can c�nl� b� granted on horr�esiead �r�perty if my anrtuai inc�me
€�c�es r��t �s���d th� sum crf�39,39�.t�f� � c�f �tant�ary i, 2�2€� {sut��ect tca annua} adjustrr�ent by
t3t� ���s�:. � P`�e� tn€i�x ft�r the T�r� �ity �}, t�a# I a� �5 �� ars c�f age c�r ��der, c�r t� t
� p�m�nentty t�r t+�t�lly di�abled �regardless of age). 1 aiso und�rstand that I must su���y
���rif�e�ti�� c+#'r�� is�c�rne ir� t�e fc�rra� ��rny �atest Feder�i Inccar�e T� f��, c�� �vritteee� i�����
verifie�.�ic�r� ��rn th� �o�i� Security Ag��cy, ar a cc�py n�rr�y la�t S�ci�1 S���ity +����, I� th�
cas� vf disabilit3�, I rnust subrnit veriF�cation in t}ze iarm of a physi�ian's stat�ment.
F���exrn��, ���erst�z�d ih�€ i must renew tiae �ef��nt ann�aPiy during tla;e term af the
deferment �d aii requirec� sup�orting ��€iments c�r infarm�.tic►n ��ust b� delivered to the �ity
n�t later th�n �pte��r 3t� af e�ch year. Deferr�d �sessments sh�II accr�e si�pie interest
duri�g the def�rment per�c�d at t�e r�te establi�h�cfi fc�r p�yinent c�iFassesstnents at the time the
�ss�ssment ���1 w�s acivpted. t3pt�n fail�re tv rene� the €Ieferment cer�ification �r u�n {�) th�
�e�tt� vf the €��ner, prc�vic�d �xt t�e ��zruiving �r successc�r c�wner �s at}��rwise noi eiigible fc�r
t�� defee��t$ (b) the sale, �sfer c�x s��a€�i�fisi�n af �he gr�r�rty� €�r any part t�erec�f; {c} if the
prc�pert�� shQ�td f�� an� re�son iase its h�rr�estea� �tat��� t�� (d} ff fiar any r��c�n ihe �City sI�all
deterrr�ane that tl�er� w�uid b� nr� hardship tt� require ir�r�edi�te or p�rti�l paym��t; ��
deferm�nt shalt t�arnn��ate aEn.€l the City Clerk shal� �rarr►ptly certify to �he ��unty Aud�tor th�
a�caunt o�`the c��ferre�i as����rnent �nc�utfing irtterest tc� be i�set�ed on ihe tax �sessr�ze�zt �r in
fu�� if the �rc��rty v��s �c�l� t�r ihe �ri�d c�ft�me f�r repayrnent €�f the originai assessme�t l�
e�t�ired.
�'�� c � � .�— w� � ��� � � .-��..� 1�-� u_.s� I,��
.. . _aa�r w_ �. � �rN.�.. � �...
� �. � ._ �
����� ��� ���������� �
� � ���--�.� �. �-�.� � � �.� . � ��,�.�ti �_ .� c � - � � �',3
-------
�� � « � _..�_ .,: �...��
�t�dda�s c�f grc�perty erwner� (Te�eph�ne} � `
#-'� c��K-t tJ. � .��.,� ,.� t-� c`-) ,. ��P, ,.__ -.���� � �
St�bscrib�� and s�vr�m t� �fore me tl�as �� �day of V��}�2.�! .�, 2f12� .
. _.�MN� � ��i�
�Cil3i'iC2� �C�2L)il:
I��ferraI graz�ted I�eferr�ll ��r►ied I3ate:
MElANIE ORTII SCHIAPKQNI
Notary Publia-Minnasota
WM � �'w .len s�. a0?A
Hopkins, MN Code of Ordinances
Sec. 2-� 20. - Deferment of special assessment.
Page 1 of 2
(a) Discretionary deferral. The city council may, in its discretion, defer the payment of any
� .
special assessment on homestead property owned by a person who is 65 years of age
or older, or who is retired by virtue of permanent and total disability. Such deferment
shall be based on the propertjr owner demonstrating he meets the following standards:
(1) The applicant must apply for the deferment not later than 90 days after the
assessment is adopted by the council;
(2) The applicant must be 65 years of age, or older, or retired by virtue of permanent
disability;
(3) The applicant must be the owner of the property;
(4) The applicant must occupy the property as a principal place of residence; and
(5) The applicant's income from all sources does not exceed the low-income limit as
established by the department of housing and urban development as used in
determining the eligibility for section VIII housing.
(b) Eligibility. The deferment will be granted for as long a period of time as the hardship
exists and the conditions as aforementioned have been met. The applicant must notify
the administrator of any change in applicant's status that would affect eligibility for
deferment.
(c) lnterest on deferred assessments. Deferred assessments shall accrue simple interest
during the deferment period at the rate established for payment of assessments at the
time the assessment roll was adopted.
(d) End ofdeferment. The entire amount of deferred special assessments is due within 60
days after loss of eligibility by the applicant. If the special assessment is not paid within
60 days, the administrator must add thereto interest at the applicable rate for the bond
issue for the project. If there is no bond issue for the project, interest will be fixed by
resolution of the council. The total amount of principal and interest from the due date
through December 31 of the following year must be certified to the county auditor for
collection with taxes the following year. If the applicant demonstrates, to the
satisfaction of the council, that full repayment of the deferred special assessment
would cause the applicant particular undue financial hardship, the council may order
that the applicant pay within 60 days a sum equal to the number of installments of
about:blank 10/27/2020
Hopkins, MN Code of Ordinances
deferred special assessments outstanding and unpaid to date (including principal and
interest) with the balance thereafter paid according to the terms and conditions of the
original special assessment.
Page 2 of 2
(e) Renewaland termination ofdeferment. The certification of deferment shall be
renewed annually by the owne,r during the term of the deferment and all required
supporting documents or information delivered to the city not later than September 30
of each year. The deferment shall terminate upon failure to renew the deferment
certification or upon:
(1) The death of the owner, provided that the surviving or successor owner is
otherwise not eligible for the deferment;
(2) The sale, transfer or of the property or any part thereof;
(3) The loss for any reason of the homestead status of the property; or
(4) Determination by the city that there would be no hardship to require immediate or
partial payment.
Upon termination of the deferment, and the city clerk shall promptly certify to the
county auditor the amount of the deferred assessment including interest to be inserted
on the tax rolls and collected in the period of time remaining in the original assessment
or in full if the property was sold or the period of time for repayment of the original
assessment has expired.
(fl Col%ction ofdelinquentassessments. In addition to the city's authority to certify
amounts due to the county for collection with property taxes, the city may also charge
delinquent accounts to a property owner's taxes as service fees as authorized pursuant
to M.S.A. §§ 429.101, 415.01, 366.011, and 366.012. These fees shall be charges on the
property owners' taxes, which shall be in addition to and distinct from any pending
special assessments levied pursuant to state law.
(Code 1986, §§ 703.01, 703.03, 703.05)
about:blank 10/27/2020
MINNESQTA STAATUTES 2017 435.193
'�
435.193 HA�S�i�P ASSESSM�NT DE�ERRAL FOR SEl�1I4RS, DISAB�,�D, OR M�ITARY
PERSONS.
(a) Notwithstanding the provisions of any 1aw to the cantrary, any county, statutnry or hame ruie charter
city, ot town, making a special assessment m�,y, at its dascreti4n, defer the payment of that assessment for
arry homestead prdperty:
(1) owned by a person 65 yeats of ag� or older or retired by virtue of a germanent and total disability .
for wrho�n it would be a hardship to make the payments; or
(2) awned by a person who is a rnember of the Minnesata Na#ional Guard or other military reserves
wha �s ordered into active military seruice, as defined in section 1q0.05, subdivision Sb or 5c, as staxed in
che person�s miTirary orders, for whom it �arould be a hardship to make the payments.
(b) Any county, statutory or hame rule charter ci�#y, or town electing to defer special assessments shatl
adopt an ordinance or resolution establishing standards and guidelines fc�r de#ermining ihe exis%nce vf a
hardsiup and for detern�ini�►g the eaistence of a disabiiity, but nothing herein shall be construed to prohibit
the determination of hardship on the basis of exceptionai a�td unusual circumstanees not covered by the
siandards and guidelines where the detetrnination is tnade in a nondiscriminatory manner and does no# give
the applicant an unreasonable preference ar advant�ge over other applica�ts.
�Iistory: 1974 c 2f1S s 7; 19i6 c 195 s 3; 1981 c 80 s 1; 2008 c 154 art � s 28
+Copvright � 2017 by the Revisor of Stakutrs, State of Minnesotm. Ail Ri�hts Reserved.
MII�FN�SC}Tt15TAT`UT'�S 2f�17 435.I95
435195 TERMINAT[QN OF RIG�T'i'tJ UEF��[tED PAYIV�ENT.
The o�t�nn to defsr i�e payment of spe�ial assessments shall terminate and aii ar�ount� accumuiated
plus applicabi� interes#, shali beecc�me due upt�n the t�ccurrenc� ��" any o� the following events: {a) ihe death
af the ovdmer, pro�v�de� that ihe s�u�e zs othenvise nat elig�bte for the tsen�fi�s hereunder; (b} the sale,
transfer �r subdivi�iun of the prm�rty �r any par# thereof; {c) if the properiy should for a�y reason Iose its
homestead status; or (d) if fvr any reason �he ta�cing acttharit� tt�fer�ing �he payn�ents shafl c��tenmir�e thai
there wou�d i� n� hardship to require irn�nediate or partial paymsni.
His#ory: 19'�1 c 2�6 s 9
�4Py�i�t � 2017 by the Rea�isor �f Statutes, State oi Minnesota. A1[ Rights Resen�ed.