CR 2003-166 Purchase Of a New Telephone System• November 18, 2003
•
Proposed Action
Staff recommends that the Council approve the following motion: Move that the Hopkins City
Council approve the expenditure of $101,000 for the purchase of a new telephone system for the
City.
Adoption of this motion will result in the installation of a new telephone system serving City
facilities.
Overview
The City's current telephone system is eleven years old. The Equipment Replacement Plan
contained $119,000 to replace the system in 2002. During the last two years the City has looked
at upgrading the software of the current system in order to prolong the life of the system. The
new facility projects, however, requires additional equipment.
The City solicited bids for both upgrading the existing system, with some additional equipment
for the new facilities, as well as completely replacing the telephone system. Only one provider
bid on the upgrade at a cost of $85,000. A completely new system will cost approximately
$101,000. Staff is recommending going with the low bidder. The next lowest bid was $108,000.
In addition to the purchase cost, there is the cost of maintenance. A new telephone system will
actually cost significantly less over the next seven years than either keeping the current system or
simply upgrading it.
Primary Issues to Consider
• What are the costs associated with this project?
• How will the project be paid for?
• What additional benefits can be had from this project?
Supporting Information
• Analysis of the Issues
Genellie
ssistant City Manager
PURCHASE OF A NEW TELEPHONE SYSTEM
Council Report 2003 -166
Council Report 2003 -166
Page 2
•
Analysis of the Issues
What are the costs associated with this project?
There are the initial system costs as well as on -going maintenance costs. The total cost of the
new system over seven years will be approximately $108,000. The estimated cost of keeping the
current system over the same period would be over $120,000. The estimated life of the new
system should be at least ten years.
How will the project be paid for?
Money is available from the Equipment Replace Fund, enterprise funds, and the money that was
budgeted for this purpose in the facility projects.
What additional benefits can be had from this project?
• Eliminate the need to dial "1" for local area codes. The current software does not recognize
the new local area codes, 612, 763 and 651 as being different from long distance area codes.
• Dial "911" directly instead of "9 911". Because you have to dial 9 in order to get an outside
line with our telephone system you cannot dial "911" directly. It is currently not possible for
the Police Department to know where an "internal" 911 call originates.
• Allows message on attendant console to be given to callers when they have been waiting a
predetermined length of time. Currently if the attendant is dealing with one caller, any
additional callers just hear the phone ring. It appears that we are simply not answering the
phone.
• Caller ID. Inbound caller ID would be a welcome addition for most employees. The Police
Department would especially find it useful. Outbound caller ID is becoming increasingly
necessary. Some people receive information showing them receiving a call from the City of
Hopkins. Others get a message that it is an out of area call. As more and more people get
caller ID they come to expect to be able to see who is calling them. Some people will not
answer calls that are not identified or have software that blocks these calls. Other people,
who receive the information that the call came from the City of Hopkins, call us back to try
to find out who called them. The receptionists have no way of knowing which employee
made the call. The new software would identify the individual employee's phone number on
caller ID displays. This feature will be able to be turned off if, for example, Police
undercover officers need to make calls that should not be identified.
• The backup emergency response center, the new fire hall, will have a backup for the
telephone system. If anything should happen to City Hall, all calls can be routed to the fire
station. (Also as part of the facility project, the new fire station will have a backup of the
City's computer system. That cost is not part of the telephone system.)
•
Council Report 2003 -166
Page 3
Alternatives
1. Authorize the purchase of a new telephone system.
2. Do not authorize the expenditure of funds.
Staff recommends Alternative #1.