CR 94-80 Street Restoration After Plumbing Repairs
.
\ 'i y 0
~
~~]ir~'~>
. April 14, 1994 , .>:.: . Council Report: 94-80
o P K \ ~
STREET RESTORATION AFTER
PLUMBING REPAIRS
Proposed Action.
Staff recommends adoption of the following motion: "Direct staff
to continue using current methods for water and sewer service
repairs. II
Overview.
Mayor Redepenning was approached by Len Coequyt of 346 11th
Avenue North with concerns that the city's sewer and water
service ordinance was unfair since it placed the burden of
maintenance on the property owner. Mr. Coequyt had recently
incurred costs to repair his water service in the street that
included substantial street restoration costs. Mayor Redepenning
subsequently asked staff to review this issue to determine if our
policies should be changed.
. Primary Issues to Consider
o What is our current policy on water and sewer service
maintenance?
o How does our policy compare to other cities?
o What is a typical street repair cost for a plumbing repair?
o Could our policy be changed?
o Should our policy be changed?
Supportinq Information
o Analysis of Issues
o Water and Sewer Survey
(;~ >c:1L-:iftJ
Lee Gustafson, ublic Works Director
.
..-..--
.
Council Report: 94-80
Page 2
.
Analysis of Issues
o What is our current policy on water and sewer service
maintenance?
The City of Hopkins Water and Sewer ordinance places the
responsibility for maintenance on the property owner for the
entire service. This includes the service connections on
the main for both water and sewer, and the entire service
into the house excluding the water meter.
o How does our policy compare to other cities?
The attached survey was completed earlier this year and
indicates that of the 28 cities surveyed, 13 have the same
policy as Hopkins. Of the other 15 cities half of them
require that the property owner maintain the entire sewer
portion and only a portion of the water, and the other half
of the cities require the property owner to maintain the
services to the property line.
o What is a typical street repair cost for a plumbing repair?
. Staff has estimated that a street repair cost for a typical
plumbing repair is approximately $500. However, in the case
of Mr. Coequyt, the repair cost was much higher Slnce the
hole was significantly larger than most, and curb and gutter
needed to be replaced.
o Could our policy be changed?
policies can always be changed. Our policy could be revised
similar to one of the polices listed on the attached survey,
or in whatever fashion Council would desire.
o Should our policy be changed?
Staff strongly fees that our policy should not change and
that is should remain as written. The policy has served the
ci ty and residents well for many decades, and has been
viewed as fair in most instances. Staff does not feel that
one odd situation where there were higher than normal repair
costs justifies changing the policy. Furthermore, if the
policy is changed it would increase our operational costs
due to the increased labor and/or contractual costs.
.
. ..
z ~ :3: ~ t"i t"i ~ ~ GJ t:Ij (') (') tl:1 tl:1 tl:1 t:D ~ 0 )I
t:Ij 0 H H 0 H 0 0 ~ 0 ~ ~ t"i ~ H .
~ c:: z z Z 1-:3 ~ (J) t"i trJ t< t"i 0 0 0 0 t-3
. Z Z Z GJ 1-:3 tr:I t-3 0 Z en ~ 0 0 0 H ~ to<
::r: 0 tr:l t:Ij t"i <: H trJ t-3 ~ ~ ~ Z
0 1-:3 t-3 ~ tr:l H Z Z I-d ~ t:D t'i t"l H t:Ij :II
I"Ij 0 0 t"l G'l ~ t"i H l< t< Z )I
tr:l Z Z (') t"i r.n <: ~ z z G) t-3
~ ~ t:Ij ~ tr:l :t>' H 1-:3 tlj
Z t"l ::0 ::r: I"Ij (') 0 ~
~ t"l H tr:l ~ t:Ij Z
t:D 0 trl trJ H Z ~
tr:l ::t:>' l-< G) t-3
::t:>' ::r: t:Ij c
(') t-3 ::0
::r: r.n en
g;
H
1-3
0 t-3 (') 0 1-:3 (') t-3 I"Ij 0 0 0 t-3 (') ~ (J) n ~ r.n 0 t-3 0 (') t-3 1'0 tIl :E: 0 "':I"H~ g;
::8 0 H :z 0 H 0 0 :z :s ~ 0 c:: tIj ~ t:Ij :s 0 :s H 0 0 t:Ij ::t:>' :s QtljtD to<
Z t-3 Z t-3 t"i Z Z Z ~ H :s H ~ Z Z t-3 t"i ::8 t-3 Z "0'.:1
t:Ij (') t< tr:l I1j t< ~ H tr:l tr:l t'1 I-d tl:1 Z tr:l to Z tr:l t:Ij (') t:Ij t< ~ H t:Ij tr:l t:Ij .~ 'tI 0 1-3 to
~ c:: ::<1 ~ n ::<1 ::0 ::0 ::0 ~ ::0 ...... ~ ::0 c:: :::0 (') ::d :::0 ::0 ~~'tI tzJ
::0 y 0 t-3 H t-<: 0 tIl I tIl :E: I ~ t-3 H t< :II
1-:3 tl:1 c:: 1-:3 '"d 0 Z 11-:3 1-:3 1-:3 I"Ij t-3 ::t:>' 0 t-3 ~ 0 t-3 tl:1 t-3 0 Z I 1-:3 1-:3 t-3 O'.:ItrJO tzJ
0 ::0 0 . r. 0 0 0 0 . 0 1-:3 :s 0 t-3 :E: 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 H!:tI!:tI !:tI
tIl H (') ::t:>' ::s '"d tr:l Z I"Ij t:Ij Z r.n n ::s tI:I 1-3
~ 1-:3 en ~ t"i C (') Z ~ n ~ t"i ::d tr:l :::0 t>:l s;: 1-:3 ~ C n Z s;: (') s;: t"I H 0'.:1
0 0 H :::0 t-3 tr:l C H :::0 ::d 0 ::0 t-3 tr:l c:: t'!! 0 tzJ
H I"Ij H H Z ~ c:: :::0 H ::0 H Z t-3 t-3 H I"Ij H ~ c:: :::0 H :::0 H !:t " ....
z 18 z tr:j I~ Z tl:1 Z t:Ij 0 I~ 0 ~ z Z I~ Z t:D Z < \Q
H \Q
H 0 ....
"U t:Ij 0 I"Ij tr:l t'j trl "'d i::Ej 0 (') "'d "'d n t:Ij ::s trl tr:j tr:l I"Ij t:Ij I"Ij I-d ::d t< I"Ij ,,~ tzJ
::d ~ z ::0 ~ :t>' ~ ::d ::t:>' ::s H :::0 0 H :J:>' H ~ ::t:>' ::t:>' ::d :J:>' :::0 ::0 trl trl :::0 to ::lEI
0 (') 10 n (') (') 0 (') Z t-3 0 ::0 1-:3 () 1-:3 (') () (') 0 () 0 0 '1:1 en 0 tzJO )I
I"Ij ::r: ::s: "'d' ::r: ::r: "'d ::r: i::Ej t-<: I"Ij 1-:3 t-<: ::r: ::r: t:Ij 0:: 0:: '1:1 :r: I-d '"d :t>' '"d tD 1-3
i::Ej tr:I t:Ij 0 tr:l ::0 . H '"d i::Ej tr:l tr:l H t:Ij i::Ej 1-3't1 t!j
::0 I-d t-3 ::<1 :E: I-d "'d ::0 "'d ::r: 0 0 ~ I-d ::r: 1-:3 I-d "'d ::0 "'d ::0 :::0 ::d ~ ::0 0)1 ::tl
1-:3 ~ t:Ij t-3 Z ::t:>' ~ 1-:3 ::t:>' Z ::t:>' ::8 z c:: ~ 0 ::t:>' ::t:>' 1-:3 ~ t-3 1-:3 (J) n 1-:3 ~~
t-<: ::0 ::0 t-<: t:Ij :::0 ::d t-<: ::0 t>:l (J) Z Cfl t-<: t-3 I-tj :::0 ::0 t-<: :::0 t-<: t-<: 0:: t-<: ~
1-:3 ::0 t-3 1-:3 t-3 trJ trJ :s t-3 (J) 0 t-3 t-3 t-3 1-3
. 0 t-<: n 0 t-<: t-<: 0 t< 0 ::s :::0 :t>' ::: :::0 t< t< 0 t-<: 0 0 I"Ij 0 H"':I C
:z 0 ::s ::0 :E: en tr:l Cfl tl:1 0 ::t:>' :E: :s :E: ~ :s 00
z I-d ::0 Z trl "'d I-d Z "'d t"i "'d trl ::8 t-3 Cfl '"d "d Z "d Z z ::0 Z !Z:!:tI to
trJ :t>' "d trj (J) ::t:>' ~ trj ::t:>' 1-:3 0 ::t:>' H Z t:Ij <: ~ ~ t>:l :t>' trj trl t-3 trj ...:1 ~
::d t-<: ::0 '"d t-<: t-<: ::0 t< 0 t>:l t-<: Z t-3 ::0 (') t< l< ::0 t-<: ::0 :::0 t< ::0 !:tI
(J) 0 en (J) Cfl ::0 r.n .-., 0::1 . Cfl Cfl h Cfl t!j H
::t:>' Z G)1 IH trj t-3 H ::0 "d 'tI 1-3
I-xj Z Cfl I-tj 0 I-xj trl H t>:l I-:rj ::0 0 0 "Ij "Ij "Ij z I-tj t>:l ::t:>' )I )l
0 0 . 0 :s 0 t-3 "Ij ~ t:Ij :E: 0 ::0 0 0 (') 0 en t< H :::c
::0 I-tj ::0 Z ::0 (') () Z t"i tIj :::0 ::0 t"i :::0 I-d Cfl " ~
Cfl 0 ~ t-3 trl H t-3 t>:l trJ c:: 0
0 t-3 ::0 0 ::0 0 ::r: '"d t-3 0 ::0 N 0 0 0 0 Z ::t:>' ~ OJ
::: 0 :E: t>:l :E: '"d t:Ij t-3 t-<: tr:l :E: :E: t:Ij :E: (J) t"i t!j
Z I1j Cfl Z "d Z ~ t< Cfl Cfl ::r: en Z z en z H t"i C :II
trJ ::t:>' t< I-tj I t>:l H I tl:1 t!j
::0 1J:l :s ::0 H ::d () 0 t-3 trJ ::0 (') ::0 ::0 n ::d t"t (') ::tl
t:Ij 0 trJ trJ :::0 t.r:.1 () ::t:>' :::0 p:: trJ H t:Ij trJ 0 t.r:.1 tr:l 0
"d >:: ::0 I-d (fJ I-d 0 Z trJ :E: Cfl t-3 "d I-d ::0 I-d Cfl ttl
::t:>' ::t:>' :J:>' Z ... "Ij to<: ::r: t< ~ ::t:>' ~ ::t:>' "Ij 1-:3 d
H () H H t-3 t-3 ::0 0 () H H H 0 Cfl ~
::0 t"i ::0 ::0 ~ t:Ij '"d en 0 t-3 ::0 ::d ::d ::0
en t>:l (fJ (J) t-3 trl ~ tr:l Z ::r: CIl (J) CIl t>:l
~ () ::r: N t< 1-:3 ~I 0 ..q
I~ t-3 l;g I~ ~ :::0 ~ ~
. .
. I~
Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z t"i trl :s H t< en kn- z OH
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 H ~ :Po Z I-d t:Ij t-3 U1 0 HtD
Z (') t-3 :J:>' (J) ::d . I t-3
t:Ij ::r: trl 1-:3 H t>:l 0 "d to< 1-3
::0 p:: ::d I t:Ij 0 t:Ij =
I1j I trj tIl t-3 ~ "':It'!!
~ Z t-3 I-d O::d
t< 0 en ~ ::r: ~ :d H !Z:tzJ
...... t-3 t:Ij t:Ij t-3 t:l
t-3 (J) ::d t< '"d ~ !ilii:
0 trJ t:Ij t-3 () :Po H
:s tr:l ::r: H H Z G:lt<
I"Ij t:Ij t-3 H t-3 :d I-:rj n ...:1
::d ::d zto<: t-3t"i
01 G) () c::
'"dU1 0 0
. . 0 (f) I:rJ
'*' I~ {f'J
ZZ Z Z Z t-<:t-<: Z t-<: Z Z Z z t-<:Z z to<: z nl:'1:11
00 0 0 0 trJt:Ij 0 t:Ij 00 0 0 t:Ij0 0 t:Ij 0 ~HO
(J)(J) (J) CI:l CIl ::-to
t'!lt"l
:+ :+ :+ lI- lI- Q t::l
:+ :+ * * * tzJl-3
...:1 0
. , .
~ :+ :+ :E: :E: en en C/l C/l r:n "'d "'d 0 0 n 'tI:E:
:+ :+ 0 ~ t-j ~ 1-3 1-3 "'d ~ t'i ~ ~ H III OJ
:+ 0 ~ H ~ H 1-<: 0 ~ o.Clrt
. t1 N t"i "'d t"t ~ H 0 3: Z t1 .-< ro ro
tx1 :l:oI E :J;JI 0 z ~ 0 0 ~ Ii
~1-'3: St'i rttc ~t1 1-'-00 IlItt:1(Jl c::: 1-3 c: c:: ~ (j) c:: t:"'I to .........
III III 01 III 1-" III I-' '1 OJ UlIllHi ::llllrt ::0 ::P' t""I H ::r: ~ I-:l tr;j (Jl
rtO::l 1-" rt ;:>:;'1lI 0;:>:;' :>G" 1-<.:l3 I<: t-j (Jl 0 '1:J ::r: (1)
ro ?;' I-<.: ::trt ([) 1-'. O"([) l1o.rt (l)t""I t<:l "'d Z ~ ~
,.., . I-' Cfl ;;j 1-'<: ([)0I::r 'grtg ::d ~ "tl I< t'l"j (l)
, o () ([) ([) ([) 1-'. Cfl I-' ([) ~ Ii
Hl 1-'. () 131-' ~rt> o ......1-'.
n- () 01 ::E: I-' o ~ () tr13Ul en
'0 1-" PI Ii 0 o m ::l ...... i-'rt> ([)
ll.I rt> ;;j ro c () Ul"'drt ro Ii
I-<.:Ul 0' f-J o ~ 1-'.,.., 1-'- Sll.I"'d <:
~ s p... o 0. C 0 tr 1-" (1) Ul Ul PI 1-"
Hi Ii C I-'Or.n Ii 0
ro (1l III ::E:OIX'
::l ::l I-' Cfl I-' (D Ii (l)
rt 1-'_ p... ~ ::r
;trt ~ ::r>;, tr Hlt'l::r !tl tt:I ~ en
1-" 0 (l) (D (D 0' o III 0 ::l rt 1-'- 0 rn ~ 0 0 0 ::: (Jl 1-3 1-3 ::E: (Jl ~ m I::Ej 0 i'I:j~He C
0 C S Hll-' ,.., >;' Cflli~ :E: t'l"j ~ ~ ~ :;t:.o I::Ej 0 0 ::t>' t<:! t<:l X ~ Ot':ltD 11
H::1 I-' ([) r-t o Ul rt~ a z ::: f-3 z Z f-3 ::: , ~ 1-3 ~ () Z :dID <:
Hl(D 0. Ii 0 rt(l) t'l"j tr;j tr:I t'Ij tr:l tr:I tI:I tr:I () "'d tr:l tr:l tr:I trJ tr:l .,) 'tl 0 to3 ([)
P. <: 0 (l) ::r C ti~Hi ::0 ::0 ::0 ::0 ::d ~ ::0 ~ c::: ::0 f-3 ~ ::d ::0 "'d :;0 ~~'tl ~
rtrt i-' (l)::r i-' (l)1lI1-' ro 1-" ~ 0 0 8
1-" ::l 01 rt 1-'- ::1 0. (l) '0 >< 1-3 f-3 r-3 ~ I-:l r-3 1-3 1-3 tJ:l "'d f-3 f-3 r-3 l-3 l.'IJtl!lO
::r::r :>G" ::r;:.;- ~o.i-' rtti 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 "tl 0 0 0 "'lj 0 f-l:d~
ro (D (D 1-'-<: ro ro o III en t"I ~ 0 tl:I 1-3
(')Hi Hiro '1 m 1-" I-'-u_ ::l ?: ?: (') ~ ~ ~ (') ~ r-3 H 0 ~ () ~ ~ ~ t" 1-1
rt rtUl o rt <'OX' tt:lrol-<.: ~ c::: 0 Z "d q ~ 0
1-"PI 0 C::r 1-'.,.., (l) () H H H H H ::d H "'d I::Ej H ~ H H Z
rto ::r(l) '1 (l) 0 o rt~ Z Z tx1 Z Z Z tJ:l Z ~ Z tl:l Z IZ
I-<:rt lD ,.., 0' 1-" lD 1-" rt '0 Ii
0 1-<:<: trli ::1 0 (D ::r 0
0.0 ::r 1-'. J-I)I,Q ::101tr t'l"j tr:I "U "'d "'d t<:l trl trl t-l:l t<:! () '"d ~:i
o Hi 0' III () o Ul Ii '"d 0 ''01-' X :;t:.o ::d ::d ~ ::P' ::P' ::P' :J;JI :;to' c::: ::d
ro ::l ,.., ro Xrt 00'::r '0(0 () () 0 0 0 () () () (J n ::0 0 t'l!O
tt:I 0 l.Q (l) ~ 0 S Ii ~ lD S tr:I ::r: "'d "'d '"d ::r: ::r: ::r: ::r: ::r: to "'d tD
C lD I-' ::1 Ul "'d trl t<:l trj tr::I 1-3'tl
::l Ii ;;j 1-'. ::To r-t ;:>:;' l,Q 1-" 8 "'d ::d ::d ::d "'d "'d "'d "'d '"d tJj ::0 0)1
00" rt o ::l 1-'- ::r ::r........lD ::1 0 ::t>' 1-3 t-3 8 >' >' ~ ~ ~ 0 8 g;:~
rt" ::r rt"ro o 01 lD~rt ~::1 "'lj ::d I< K: I< ::0 ::0 ::0 :x: to<:
C/l (l) ::r::1 0 1-3 8 t-3 1-3 1-:3 f-3 1-3
. ort" 1-'- o Hi rtl,Q SO::r ~ to<: 0 0 0 1-<: ~ I<: t<: t<: :;t:.o 0 Hi'I:j
~ 0 Ii ::1 Ii PI C (l) rtll1 ~ ::E: ::E: Z ::E: 00
::1'0 tt:I ro ::r0> 1-" I-' 1-" o 0 (') ~ z z Z "'d '"d '"d "'d "'d t1 Z Z~
rtO> O>rt ::1 0. Ii 0 t:r:l trJ tr;j >' ::P' ::t>' ::P' ::P' tr:I .,)
() Ii rt ::rN nO 0' 0 ::0 t<: ::d ::0 ~ I< ~ t< I<: t< :::: ~ l:d
C ro 0 ro ro rtl-''"d <: 1-'- I"'(j en rn rn rn Cf) (/) tr:l l!j
Ii C/l C/l I-"rt o 1-"0 o ::1 r 1-3 'tl
0''0 n- () rt::r f'i'i-' 1-'.0 '3j trJ "'lj "'lj "'lj "'lj I-rj trJ ~
0 1-"0 1-<.:(1) rt (D }-I. 0. 1-'- '"d 0 :x: 0 0 0 0 0 ::0 H
Ul ::1 ::r rtl-' ::r () p.. ::d ~ () ::0 ::0 l;lj ::0 ~ l:l:I
rt{Jl (D '"<01 1-'-0' (I) rt I-<: ::rlt) 0 tr:I
o 1-" Ii ::10" 0 01 ::1 "'d 0 "'d 0 0 0 0 0 ~
"dO" () o 1-" Ul 0 ::r I-h <:rt tr:I ~ f-3 ::E: ::s ::8 ~ ::E:
~ }-I- }-I- :E:Hl rt<: o 0 ....- 1-'_01 ::u z z z z z z 0
I-' rt ::1 1-'- 01 (D :3 ::r' <: ::11-' 1-3 I-rj
rt 1-'- I-<.: ID ID I-' It) Pl ID l,Q.., t< ~ 0 ::0 ::u l;lj ::u ~
;:rrf' o,p, I-'ro . ::::l t>j ::u t<:l tr:I t<:l t<:l tr:I
rot..::: 0" ~ ~ I,QO Cfl (0 0 'tJ 'lj 'tJ 'lj hj 'lj
t..::: 1-" (I) '00 0 rol-h rt'O ::s ::P' :3: ::P' ~~ ::P' :;t:.o
1-'- o ::l It) '1 01 Z H tI:I H H H H H
o ::l ::1 Ii l-d I-'.rt It) 1-'- tr:I ::0 t-3 ::u ::0::0 ~ ::0
01 Ii l,Q rt("t rt rt::r (D Ii ::0 Cf) t<:l tr.l tr.l (Jl en tr.l
::1 (D ..... ::r ID rt~ ~
::l\Q 11 o (D Hl rtS
o III It) ? ...... 0 0 rtm
rtli I"'t Ii ..... o C
Cfl litr:J Z Z '2: '2:2: Z 2:2: Z 2: Z OH
1-'0. l-d "d ro ti Ii () 0 0 0 00 0 00 0 0 0 I-ItD
ro C/l 0 0 0 0' 0 ::l::r' I 1-3
::l ::1 ::P' :+ '-<"'3
lOrt I-' 0.0 C PI
m 1-'. ?;' (/) ==
01 0 1-'. () ::I ("tf-J 'Om (fl (/) h:Jto;J
f-' 0" 11> t'Ij trJ C::~
I-'m f-' I-<.: ~ ::r'< 0Ir-t (Jl tr:I 2:to:I
'<::r It) . ll> ::s i.O~ en 0
m C 0 rt"'d III 0> tJ:l ~~
::r~ Hl 0 ("to' I-'-Ii en tr;j
0 n ::I ::rli ::1 It) tr:I t"i Ci)~
~ 1-'- Ii C C/l ro!' t<:l 0 .,)
rt::1 Ii rt ("to' ::E:
01,Q Ii Ii ::rlt) to
0 m c 1ljG) 0> }-I- trJ
Hl~ 0 ::1 0 Ii 0 '<::I t"'
. Hill> Ii rt rt 01-' ~l,Q ~
rt ~ I-' 1-'- l-do.
rto> 0 I-<: 0 It) It) }-I.
::rli ti ::1 ti ::1 I-'Pl Z Z Z ZZ Z 1-<:1-<: Z Z t< 01:"121
ID 01 rt ~ rt I-' 0 0 0 00 0 trlt<:l 0 0 trl ~HO
0 rt ::r '<<: I-' mr:n CIl ~c::
OHl 1-'. (l) 1-'- QI '1 It) to:It't
~Hl 0 Hi 01-' ro PI * * *G:l 0
::l ::1 () ~I-' l-dX' :+ lIo * t'il"'3
It)Hl 1-'- rf' ::1 (D PI .,) 0
1""/ 0 rt It ::t 0>'"< }-I. 01
Cfl 1"1 0 I-<.: (D Ii~ Ii rt
___ ____0___
, . ,
S PI ~ ~ rtS8 [; "O::r:: t<.l 1Il ::r:: () :3:::r:: IJj ::I ::r:: IJj PI {Jl ""':l ~ {Jl 8 1:1:"'0 ;€
PI Ul 0 0 ::rO::r l-j PI t:l o PI ~ o PI ~ t'D PI ~ ::l rt 0 t'D::r . PI PI
]-I-{Jl ::I Z t'D l-j (I) Cf.l o Ul t<:I o TJ1 t< C Ul 0 (I) (Jl 0 0.011 0 ~ ill lQrt
. ::lilll.O G1 51(1)'< 8 "0::1 Z ::1::1 Cf.l ::l ::l 0 a.::I 0 "0 ~ t'D (D (D
. Ul H ill .. . .. 8 0. .. ,,:; ro .. :3: 1Il :e: til-h 11
Ul t-t E l1lrta. Z ti rt '1:l rt ~ rt t-t p.rt H t-J- rt PI S g. :l!w-....
PI o::rO G1 rt ~ t-t {Jl t< Z p.ort :J:lII Cf.l
rt::>:;' 0\0 PI Cf.l '<p.. P. ~ PIp.. Z 11p. G1 t'D (D PI I-' 1-:1 ill
::rill t<:l ::I ::l PI 0 H 0 ]-1-0 ro 0 8 ~ ]-I-ti ]-1'0 tl:I :e:
(D 0 0 ~ ::I :s: p. '::1 (') "0::1 0 PI ::l ::I :e: !:d ill
Ul::r HlOrt ::I ::l H t'D H rt(D t1j .....ro z ..... S t-J- ti
ro PI ::l p..ro tr:I Z Z OJ ::>;'UlOJ 1'1 ::I ~
(Jl rtroOJ PI Z ::1'OJ 8 0 ]-1- ]-I- rol.O Cf.l
n ::r Ul PI PI tIj tIj ]-I_OJ Ii P. ::I "0 t:I ro
00. ro "0 Ul ::I ::I ~ ro ::l ~ ::l ::l ~CDti 1-'(') 1'1
Ul 0 ill ro Ul'< '< 0 ~~ ~ l.O'< PI ]-1- m <:
rt::l n ti Ul ro z :e: PI ~ ro o rt ~ ]-1-
{Jl (l) o Ul Ul :e: l-j '< ~ 0'< IJj rtti t-J- I-' "0 ro t-J- 0
Ul 0 ro (l) ro C (l) ~ ::rro l-j::>:;'..... S ro H CD
O"Ul rt::lHl 1'1"0 rt .....rt 0 (l)"O Ul PI (D Ul 1-:1
(1) (1) Ul 0 SlJI-' ~ lJj a.~ 0 '<I--' . :e: n ::I ~ Cf.l
n <: rtol1 tIj ,,:; SlJ ::r(1) rtlQ c
PI (l) n PI tr ~ SlJO" t-t "On ]-I-S ~ SlJ t< l-j
C ti o::lrt n n C () .....C to< l-j (D o (1) <:
Ul PI O"SlJ::r (1) CD rt ::r:: Ulrt z o S ::r::l <: 01 (l)
(1) I-' Ul 51 ~ 0 0'(1) rt (1) tIJ ~
ti (1) Ul ~ :e: "O:e: '1:l SlJ ::I ]-I_Ul :EI
rt51 ]-I_Ul S ort 0 ~ tfrt Ul l-j tIJ
::rPl ::l (1) PI 0 ~ 11 0 ~ 1-'TJ1 I ro "
(l) ]-I- \.Q ~ ]-I- ::rUl C ,,:; o C ~ "2(') en
~::I ~~ I--' t:l tJl-' ~ :e:"< '0 ~
rtl-j? . p. :t:' PIp. -::r 0
Hll-j ::r \.Q(l) t-t tr::l G1 o (l) PI PI ::l H
(1) (l) (OenHl (Ort "0 t<.l I--' .. 0 C.;t :e: ::l en !z:
(D"O S (0 0 ~ ti ~rt t'1 I-' PlLQ (0
1--'1-' l-j Hl 0 0 a.tr N:::(O en "
PI C <: ti o tr tf Ul PI tr! tl:I
]-1-0 '0 ]-I" l-j C PI t'D Ul Z PI C HlUl rt 't:I
rtCD n I-' trrt 0' I--'en en rt Ii (l) 0 t'l
51 rt(DPI I-' I-'CD ~ en o l-j :J:II
]-1.(1) o~ lri C '< en (D :e: 51 <: rt Q
Ul ::l n rt l-j ]-I- rt O"Ul ~ Ul 0 ]-I- ::r tIJ
rtrt I-'::r PI o ~ ~ Ul C '0 0 (l) :c
o ::r PI p..(l) Ul ::l tIj . I-' Ii (l) tIJ
::rUl p..rol-' ]-I-~ Ul p..:e: t< p.. o rt ..0 !2:
. (1)0. CD Ul ::l (D Ul 0 ~ C 1-:1
]-I-C 'Ort l.O::r Ul . C "0 "00 (0
s: (0
l-j ro ]-I- ::r en lJ.I Ul I-' Ii Ii 0'1 Ul
rtro o <: . a. H 0 rt
l-jrt .Z rt _
~~ HlCD tr ~ ~- t-J-
ro 0 C Z PI 0
Ul :e: PI tIj tf l-'n ::I
"Ort ]-I-en -{Jl-rt 0 Ul ~ I--'
O::r I-'Ul ~Ii lJ.I (0 0 ~ ]-1- ::r 0
::l co I-'ro NC ~ Z ::I OJ
Ul . ::I p.. :e: ~ co ::I Hl
]-I- l.O~ 11l::>:;' OJ OJ PI ~ lQ
tJO 0 I-' rt ~ Ul (')(l) PI
]-I-g ]-I- (I) Ul Ul
<: 11l "O~ ro s: CD t-J- rt Ul
I-' I'D 0 ti
t-J.1'1 I'D Ul :e: -.... 0 Ul rto (l)
rtO ,,^O l-j CD ]-I- Ul c:: Ul ~ Ul
rt.
~ Ul ::r S ~ I--' (l) Z "OlQ Ul
]-1- :e: t1 ]-I- ]-I-
PI <: ro I--' PI PI ::I
51 >'<j o S (1) ~ HI ~I-'
::l CD ::l (D tr l-j Ul <: l.O
p..::l 0 rt::l '1:l PI
ro l-j ro ]-1-
::rrt t-t rt ::I 0
I--'-PI PI Hl to< (P ]-I- 0
Ort !/) C
rtrt rt l.O s: ON !/)
C ::r::r o 0 0 ::I 0 :e: .:~ (0 rt
]-I-l-j rtCO ]-I- a. c:: CD a. fIl
fIl I'D o l-h ::l Ul ~ l-j
::rUl 0 \.Q ::r:: (l) rtrt Hl
1.....1_0 CD PI <:-{Jl- Hl ~ ::ro 0
C Hl t-J-::I CD w 0" Ii PI (0 l-j
Ulrt l-j ]-I- l-j~ co 0 Cf.l ~"O
rt::r rt l-' l-h S 8 :e: PI ~ rt
o PI rto 0 ::r ::r
LQro :e: l-j ::ro l-j rt ~ 0 1--'''0 CD
ro ]-1- ::l~ CD . (0 ::r 0 I-' fIl (0
::l l-j Ul 0 (0 c:: ro o l-j :e:
CD Ul Ul (DO H rt
ti Ul ro CD () en PI~ OJ
PI 0 ti :e: (0 l-h 0 C {Jl fIl rt
I-' ]-I- <: ro C rt '1:l C fill--' ro
I--' t-J-l-j >:: 0 ::I t-J- ~ tr (0 ]-I- l-j
C~ o~ "Ol-j n I-' p. (Jl ::l
(1) 1--'-
. "0 CD ::l ]-I- ]-I- Ul (1) PI
~rt ]-1- m c I--' rt ~ <: ~ ::l
ro::r OJHl (1) ::l ~ ]-I- PI p..
ro (1) ::l Ul a. :e: ;€ m ::l 51
"O~ p..rt . (0 ]-I- tr ~ 1--'- ~O Ul
::r <: rt ]-I- t< 0 <: PI
op.. lJJ (l) ro ::r I-' N ::l Ul (0 ::I
HlO Ul l-j I--' I--' :x:- rt ]-1-
Ul (D 0 rt ]-1- 8 rt l-j n rt
rt::l (0 "0 ::r ::I ~ ::r CD C PI
::ro Ul ]-I- (0 ]-I- \.Q PI (0 l-j l-j
(1)rt Ul Ul p.. Ul . rt rttf ~
.
,
~8rt8 00 trOO (f.I"d:::E:
1'D::r::f::t 8 I'D~ "dOJOJ
. a I'D ro ro ::l ~ :;d \.Q rt
0'< s= ro 1-'" l-II'Dro
::l ::l (j Hl::l Z ~
Ul ro 1-'" 8 1-'" \.Q G"l~-
rtp,l~rt ::I: rt 00
~ I-' '< 0 Ul"d "d I'D
~tIltJ' Z " p,I :t:' ~
aoOo. t< ~ ~ ro
rt XO 7';' ~
1-'- ~ I'D
O::r Ul ~ en
::l p,I ::l 0 ro
. <: (0 ::l ~ Ii
I'D ~ 0 I-' <:
rt 0. 1-'-
rta ()
::rOp,l p,I (0
(0 Ii tIl tIl 00
:0 Ul tIl C
ro (0 Ii
\.Q tIl tIl <:
p,I OJ tIl tIl ro
tIl ::l '<
o.rt rt
(}::l::r ::r
o ro I'D I'D
~ ~ Ul I'D
to' ro ::l
p,I () () rt
::I 0 0 1-'"
'<~tIl ~
~rt (0
Ii (0 Ul
Ii . ()
(0
to' 1-'- 1-'-
rt
\i;'Hl8 '<
(}:::::r HI
(0 (0 ro
(0'< 0
. rto.() Ii
::r(O::t rt
ro?p,I ::r
1-'- Ii ro
Ii rt \.Q
::r(O ()
~ ro 0
tIl
p,I Ii OJ rt
1-'-
::l m -{J} 0
tIlrtol>o HI
0
OJ 1-'-0 S
rtUl" OJ
0 1-'-
~o ::l
rtOJ
::r 1-'- HI ~
(00.1-' ro
OJ ~
H)rt I-'
Ul 0 p,I
OJ Ii ~ ()
~ ro ro
(0 0 () S
~ 0 (0
rtrtg ::l
rt
1-'-0 ro Ul
SHla
(0 rt Ul
rt 1-'-
rt::r() rt
Oro::r 1-'"
p,I ::l
~ ~ \.Q
tIlp,l\.Q
p,I rt (0 HI
<: ro .. 1-'-
. (0 Ii Ii
-~ (0
Ul ::r
o ro 1-'- to'
::I ~ () Ii
(0 ::r 0
Ii rt
Ul () ro
rtHlO a
~ ~ <: rt
ro ::: ro 1-'-
(0 p,. Ii 0
rt" tIl ::l